We want our neighbor’s £33,000 luxury garden shack demolished – we have no privacy and it has reduced the value of our home

FUMING residents are desperate to see their neighbors’ luxury garden shacks demolished, as they say it’s a total invasion of their privacy.

Michael and Nicola Illingworth, whose outdoor space is overlooked by the high-end sheds, have also complained that they have lowered the value of their home.

10

David Carr’s shed can be seen behind the Illingworth fenceCredit: NNP
Neighbor Brian Edwards has a hot tub in his high-end cabin

10

Neighbor Brian Edwards has a hot tub in his high-end cabinCredit: NNP

They claim that one of the cottages has water dripping down the gutter into their garden – a nightmare for them and any potential buyer.

And the other is a permanent eyesore that makes your dog bark.

The only solution they now see to the problem is to knock them both down.

Nicola, who grew furious when the council subsequently granted planning permission to her neighbors, said: “People come over and say, ‘What on earth is this?’

I've been ordered to scrap the caravan as neighbors say I'm renting out my £170,000 house
I get my money back after paying my neighbors £237,000 over 18ins

“We assume that the value of the house will have gone down.

“We will not sell and are considering what we can do to improve the situation.”

She added that the couple could install a screen or even raise the fence, but admitted “the irony is we’d need a permit for that.”

Dad-of-two David added that neighbor Brian Edwards’ cubicle is causing their Labrador pup Pippa to bark uncontrollably.

“When there are people on the patio, our dog starts barking,” he said.

“It has affected our lives in many ways.

“We have big windows downstairs so we can’t get away from that. We feel it has completely invaded our privacy.

“It definitely created an atmosphere. When we walk past them, it’s like looks can kill.”

Michael claims neither Brian, 43, nor his colleague David Carr, who spent a whopping £33,000 on his, “never came around to explain what they do”.

And he insists things would be very different if they had spoken beforehand.

Michael, from Wynyard in Teesside, added: “When you’re buying a house, buy one big enough that you don’t have to build an outside cabin.”

But David believes officer Michael, 43, and medical journalist Nicola, 40, are just jealous because they would actually like to have a garden bar with a gym and wood-burning stove themselves.

People come over and say, ‘What on earth is that?’

Nicholas Illingworth

He said: “I honestly don’t know what Michael’s problem is.

“I think he’s probably jealous and wants one of his own. It’s not a nice atmosphere.”

David, managing director of a gas and utility company, has spent tens of thousands on his luxurious cabin, which comes complete with a wet bar, pool table and playground for his children.

The 49-year-old, who lives in his large family home with his wife Sarah and children Zachary, 10, and Jayme, 5, said he built it over the lockdown because he couldn’t go to the pub.

David, who insists his shed doesn’t make any noise, said: “Michael bought his house after I got mine and my cabin was being built when he moved in.

“He complained to Bellway, the builder of the houses, but they didn’t act because I didn’t need a permit.

“I wasn’t worried as I knew my cabin was compliant. I got my builder to come and check it again and he said it was fine.”

David said Michael then tried to get him to the council and he later got a letter saying they wanted to come out and investigate.

The council gave him the all-clear – but he says the threats have come further.

David claims Michael’s mum even confronted him over the fence and berated him for “you and your loud music” – but he cheekily hit back, telling her he was only doing it to “annoy” her.

Brian's cabin can be seen behind the fence, ruining the Illingworth's life, they say

10

Brian’s cabin can be seen behind the fence, ruining the Illingworth’s life, they sayCredit: NNP
The view from the couple's house

10

The view from the couple’s houseCredit: NNP
One of the sheds can be seen over the fence of Michael and Nicola's garden

10

One of the sheds can be seen over the fence of Michael and Nicola’s gardenCredit: NNP

The Wynyard Estate is a sprawling and luxurious development where homes sell for an average of half a million pounds.

It’s home to former Dragon’s Den star Duncan Bannatyne and footballers like Tommy Miller and Steve Baker.

Brian lives next door to David with his family and has a smaller cabin in his backyard that he built for relaxing.

However, his shed is the one that Nicola and Michael have the biggest problem with, as they say the raised porch has ruined their privacy.

After the couple filed a complaint, Brian had to apply for retrospective approval, which has now been granted.

A hot tub rests on the cabin’s elevated deck and also has a dart board, indoor gym, play area, and fridge for beers.

Brian said: “I work from home and have a two-year-old son. I have decided to have the cabin built due to the lockdown.

“I have a hot tub that I use for hydrotherapy because I have early onset arthritis.

“I also have a mini fridge for drinks. We’ve never had parties in it.”

Brian claims that when he moved in he went around, introduced himself to the neighbors and bought everyone a bottle of wine.

But he admitted: “I could tell from the start that the couple who complained were not happy.

“You were the only ones who didn’t say thank you.”

Addressing the issue of the water leak, Brian said, “It has a drainage system that drains water not only from our yard but also from hers.”

We're scared of losing kids after the landlord kicked us out for 'mixing up rent'
I was shocked when the doctors told me I got pregnant TWICE in a week

He added that the couple’s complaint had sparked “a month of worry” – and that living with the couple had “not been nice”.

But he claims to have “the support of many neighbors”.

David has a full bar and beverage selection in his cabin

10

David has a full bar and beverage selection in his cabinCredit: NNP
There is also a pool table and a playground for his children

10

There is also a pool table and a playground for his childrenCredit: NNP
David has an old Pac Man machine in his den

10

David has an old Pac Man machine in his denCredit: NNP
The row above the garden shacks erupted in the posh Teeside housing estate

10

The row above the garden shacks erupted in the posh Teeside housing estateCredit: NNP
David says he has planning permission for his luxury shed

10

David says he has planning permission for his luxury shedCredit: NNP

Leave a Comment